MLB has 4 matches on Wednesday, September 9. Below is the full slate with bookmaker prices and the probabilities those prices imply once the margin is removed.
Fixtures and odds
| UTC | Match | Home | Away | Implied |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01:41 | Athletics vs Toronto Blue Jays | 2.49 | 1.54 | 38.2% / 61.8% |
| 01:41 | San Diego Padres vs Washington Nationals | 1.52 | 2.48 | 62.0% / 38.0% |
| 01:46 | San Francisco Giants vs St. Louis Cardinals | 1.88 | 1.92 | 50.5% / 49.5% |
| 02:11 | Los Angeles Dodgers vs Cincinnati Reds | 1.30 | 3.54 | 73.2% / 26.8% |
Odds are decimal, averaged across 15 books (BetOnline.ag, 888sport, Unibet (FR), Coolbet, Betclic (FR), 1xBet). "Implied" strips the bookmaker margin so the numbers add up to 100%.
Match by match
Athletics vs Toronto Blue Jays
01:41 UTC · Sutter Health Park, Sacramento · Season record: Athletics 57-87 / Toronto Blue Jays 72-72
The market leans Toronto Blue Jays at 61.8%. Prices come from 15 books, and they differ by 13.9% on the widest side.
San Diego Padres vs Washington Nationals
01:41 UTC · Petco Park, San Diego · Season record: San Diego Padres 76-68 / Washington Nationals 67-79
The market leans San Diego Padres at 62.0%. Prices come from 9 books, and they differ by 8.8% on the widest side.
San Francisco Giants vs St. Louis Cardinals
01:46 UTC · Oracle Park, San Francisco · Season record: San Francisco Giants 59-85 / St. Louis Cardinals 72-72
The market can barely separate them — 50.5% against 49.5%. Prices come from 13 books, and they differ by 10.1% on the widest side.
Los Angeles Dodgers vs Cincinnati Reds
02:11 UTC · Dodger Stadium, Los Angeles · Season record: Los Angeles Dodgers 86-57 / Cincinnati Reds 69-74
The market leans Los Angeles Dodgers at 73.2%. Prices come from 13 books, and they differ by 21.0% on the widest side.
What the market is saying
- Closest on paper — San Francisco Giants vs St. Louis Cardinals: 50.5% vs 49.5%.
- Most one-sided — Los Angeles Dodgers vs Cincinnati Reds: the market gives Los Angeles Dodgers 73.2%.
- Where books disagree most — Los Angeles Dodgers vs Cincinnati Reds: 21.0% between the best and worst price.
- Average bookmaker margin — 5.5% across the slate.
Reading the slate
The Los Angeles Dodgers present the day's most lopsided matchup, with the market pricing them at a 73.2% implied win probability against Cincinnati. This 21-percentage-point gap between the two sides is substantially wider than anything else on the slate, making it the clearest consensus in the market. The Dodgers' pricing is remarkably consistent across 13 different books, with only a 5.3% margin between the tightest and loosest odds—suggesting little disagreement about their heavy favoritism.
San Francisco and St. Louis stand in stark contrast at the other end of the spectrum. The Giants are priced at virtually even money with a 50.5% implied probability, making this the closest contest the market expects. Despite this near-parity, bookmakers show considerable scatter, with a 10.1% spread across 13 books. This divergence signals genuine uncertainty about how to price the matchup, even as the consensus settles near a coin flip.
Toronto's road trip to Oakland occupies the middle ground in terms of decisiveness. The Blue Jays are favored at 61.8%, but the 13-book consensus carries a wider 13.9% spread than any other fixture, suggesting more variance in how individual sportsbooks assess this contest. San Diego's home game against Washington lands squarely between these poles—the Padres are clear favorites at 62.0%, but the market speaks with more unified voice here, with just an 8.8% spread across nine books.
Prices captured 2026-09-08 00:00 UTC. Odds move.